Colorectal
Signal score, how each part rates
ActionabilityPrevalenceStakesEvidence strengthNovelty
See the full rubric →Risk of Distant Metastasis and Oncologic Outcomes of Clinical Near-Complete Responders After Neoadjuvant Therapy in Rectal Cancer: A Meta-Analysis.
Clinical takeawayWeigh the higher metastasis and regrowth risk when offering watch-and-wait to near-complete responders; this analysis compares response groups and does not test whether surgery improves outcomes.
What it foundNear-complete response after neoadjuvant therapy for rectal cancer is associated with higher risk of distant metastasis (16.8% vs 7.3%; RR 2.31) and local regrowth (32.8% vs 19.7%; RR 1.75) compared to complete clinical response.
ContextTen studies, 1,763 patients; definitions of near-complete response and reassessment timing varied.
No standard claimed for this paper
Every paper is compared to the standard governing its question. This one is not: either no standard in the corpus matches it, or the comparison did not hold up on review and was withdrawn rather than published unverified. Both are logged.
Marcolin P … Messaris E · Diseases of the Colon and Rectum · IF 3.5 · PubMed ↗