Nutrition
Signal score, how each part rates
ActionabilityPrevalenceStakesEvidence strengthNovelty
See the full rubric →Assessment of tools for the diagnosis of malnutrition and ICU outcomes in critically ill adults: A comparison study.
Clinical takeawayContinue using SGA for malnutrition assessment in critically ill adults, as AAIM lacks validity, prognostic utility, and agreement with SGA.
What it foundAAIM overestimated malnutrition prevalence (70.9%-75.5% vs 46.3% by SGA), showed low specificity (28.6%-32.4%), and had poor agreement with SGA (κ = 0.066-0.073), while SGA predicted prolonged hospital stay (OR 1.48) and ICU mortality (HR 2.26).
ContextConfirms SGA as the preferred tool for malnutrition assessment in critically ill adults, challenging the utility of AAIM in this population.
No standard claimed for this paper
Every paper is compared to the standard governing its question. This one is not: either no standard in the corpus matches it, or the comparison did not hold up on review and was withdrawn rather than published unverified. Both are logged.
Stello BB … Silva FM · JPEN. Journal of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition · IF 3.2 · PubMed ↗